Choosing the right shingle color might seem like a small decision, but it can have a huge impact on your home’s curb appeal, energy efficiency, and even resale value. Shingles aren’t just there to protect your house from the elements—they also frame the entire aesthetic of your exterior. Let’s walk through how to select the perfect shingle color for your home, step by step.
Start with the Style of Your Home
Your home’s architectural style plays a big role in what colors will look best. For example:
- Traditional homes like Colonials and Cape Cods tend to pair well with classic colors like black, gray, and brown.
- Modern homes often shine with bolder or more contrasting choices, such as deep charcoal or even white shingles.
- Craftsman or rustic homes look great with earthy tones like browns, greens, and weathered wood finishes.
No matter your style, aim for harmony. Your shingles should complement—not compete with—your exterior features.
Match or Contrast? Find the Balance
You have two main choices when it comes to coordination:
- Match the roof to the siding for a more uniform, subtle appearance.
- Contrast the roof with the siding to create visual interest and frame the home’s shape.
For example, light gray siding paired with dark gray shingles offers a modern, high-contrast look. On the other hand, tan siding with brown shingles provides a softer, more natural feel.
Use our Shingle Colors page to explore options like Cambridge, Dynasty, and Nordic shingles—all of which offer beautiful shades designed to suit various home styles.
Factor in Fixed Exterior Elements
Don’t forget about the parts of your home that won’t change:
- Brick or stone facades
- Chimneys
- Trim and window frames
- Garage doors
Make sure your shingle color doesn’t clash with these elements. Instead, find a shade that picks up tones from the permanent features around your home.
Consider the Light
Shingle color can look very different in bright sunlight vs. cloudy weather. Lighter shingles reflect more sunlight and can help your home stay cooler in hot climates—an important consideration in places like Missouri or Arizona.
In fact, lighter roofs can contribute to energy efficiency by reducing the heat absorbed into your attic. The U.S. Department of Energy explains how cool roofs can make a difference, especially in warmer regions.
Think About Your Neighborhood
You want your home to stand out—but not in a bad way. Before picking a shingle color, take a walk or drive around your neighborhood.
- What colors do other homes use?
- Are there HOA rules or guidelines?
- Will your color choice clash or complement neighboring homes?
Blend in just enough to stay on theme, but don’t be afraid to make a tasteful statement.
Resale Value: Be Smart with Color
If you plan on selling your home in the next few years, pick a more neutral color that appeals to a broader range of buyers. While bright red shingles might be your personal dream, classic shades like charcoal, slate, and weathered wood tend to have the most mass appeal.
A fresh roof in an attractive, neutral color can make your home feel updated and increase perceived value in the eyes of buyers.
Use Online Tools and Visualization Apps
Many shingle manufacturers offer visualization tools that allow you to upload a photo of your home and test out different color combinations. These tools can be incredibly helpful when you’re stuck between options.
Visit our Shingle Colors page to see samples from top lines like Cambridge, Nordic, and Dynasty. You’ll find colors, finishes, and shingle styles that help match your vision.
Get Professional Input
When in doubt, talk to a roofing professional. At Brody Allen Exteriors, we’ve seen thousands of color combinations in real-world settings, and we can help guide you toward a decision that looks great and lasts.
We don’t just install shingles—we help you make confident design choices that reflect your taste and elevate your home.
Final Thoughts: Your Roof, Your Canvas
Selecting the perfect shingle color doesn’t have to be overwhelming. Start with the basics: your home’s style, permanent features, and climate. Then lean on resources—like visualizers, neighborhood inspiration, and expert help.
A beautiful roof does more than protect your home—it pulls your whole exterior together.
Ready to get started? Contact us today for a consultation or color consultation.
MISSOURI'S BEST
Roofing Professionals You Can Trust
When you choose Brody Allen Exteriors, you're choosing a team that's dedicated to protecting homes. We live and work in this community, and we're here to ensure your roof is strong, durable, and built to last.
